People often rely on some anonymous internet sources for some SEO related questions that could always be answered through a few simple tests done by them. Such a test can be done to find out what is more important, urls or backlinks. You can take a word and create two different urls.
On Monday You Will See:
One site will have the keyword in the filename and domain. The other site does not have the keyword mentioned in the url. You can also publish identical texts on both the pages. Then you should link to the non-keyword url of WebmasterWorld and from Twitter. You can wait for Googlebot to crawl the sites. Then you get to index them for determining what the rankings will look like.
It is difficult to get result in just one day. Google might take more than 1 day to index new sites when it is linked to WebmasterWorld or Twitter with only a few visitors. Google returned with a few suggestions for the search terms which spell almost similar even if no typo is done.
You should not expect much result of the process on that. It is unlikely that you will get much result before 2 days.
It’s Different on Thursday:
After 3 days, if you search for the word that you used as the site name, you will find that the keyword has been scraped from Twitter. It becomes easy for the established sites to outweigh the new sites. You will find that the existing page has got updated with a new twitter message and the keyword will not exist in the live page anymore.
Friday Shows Some More Result:
On the fourth day you will notice that the non-keyword url with backlinks would likely be on the top position, i.e. rank 1. Google does not even rank the keyword url in serps. Duplicate content might be reason of that. In such cases, Google does not even display the message of “ click here for similar webpages”.
After a Month:
Probably you won’t find the page on blogspot with a rank. But the blogspot user profile will mention the phrase in the post. Graywolf’s Twitter page will also get a rank.
Three Months to Go:
After 3 months, you will surely find the exact page on blogspot page. It will only rank after clicking the text, “repeat the search with the omitted results included”. Only the user profile page will rank in the natural SERP list.